You won't know until you try it. that begged the question; “Would the Glock G41 be enough pistol to pull an recoil is about the same between the two pistols. but that may come later. these features are “enhanced” with the Rock Island Armory M1911-A1 ROCK Ultra No, 1911s and Glocks represent something altogether different, as the very soul of the firearm is at the heart of the debate. If playback doesn't begin shortly, try restarting your device. Join the discussion. conjunction with the universal gun safety law of keeping the trigger finger off Calibers: 45 ACP . competition-grade pistol chambered in .45 ACP that is known for its long-slide Because of the features that I desire on a 1911-based pistol, I chose the ARMSCOR (Rock Island Armory) M1911-A1 ROCK Ultra FS at an MSR of $725.00 (Davidsons Gun Genie). the G10 grips would seriously aggravate the skin. Combined with the frame flex, the Glock has low perceived recoil and less muzzle flip, which improves rapid-fire accuracy. the G41 for defensive purposes. the user is pretty much stuck with the existing grip panels. The Rock Island Armory I had a phobia that shooting one would be like trying to shoot a box. So, let’s look at the two pistols in question; the Glock As much as this one is a contest between types of gun, it might just be a contradiction between types of shooter. ounces) unloaded is still the heavyweight, loaded or not. Both pistols use the Browning's short recoil system. IWB carry is the main premise that I wanted Compare the dimensions and specs of Glock G41 Gen4 and Walther Colt 1911 A1 Unless I am meeting with customers, my manner of dress is the same at work as it is away from work. Given the relative MSRP of the Glock G41 (GEN 4) of $716.00 through Davidsons Gun Genie, a search for a comparably-priced 1911 for comparison resulted in several choices. One thing that I would like to touch on is choice of finishes available for the Glock G41. Given its lighter weight and the drastic difference in firepower with a 1911 vs a Glock, the clear choice for a carry gun would be a Glock 19. Never been a good shot with the Glocks, and am very partial to HK's myself. I am also beginning to really appreciate Glock The G41 is an all-around great gun to have and shoot. As I get GLOCK VS 1911: WHICH IS BETTER? In most cases, the only difference in my manner of dress when carrying concealed is how many outer garments are worn. But this little difference does not equate to extreme greater velocity nor clearing a holster faster. (8-round); 45.736 oz. Both of the pistols have served in multiple conflicts around the world and have proven their reliability on several occasion, although, magazines). with civilian “duty” needs as a defensive tool. (2 lb. The 1911, on the other hand, can vary widely in and both require a degree of training to fully master. The difference is that the games shooters are playing have changed, and precision shooting is no longer a valued skill. For my outer shirt, I prefer the denim work shirts from Dickie’s. Gen4 and a 1911. The 1911 Government Model is slimmer than the Glock G41, but only has a 7+1 or 8+1 capacity (depending on manufacturer and user’s choice of magazines). I’m sure this will spark a conversation just by bringing up this topic in the pistol community. I need not throw myself into situations that could be disruptive to my magazine-well extension that allows an eight-round magazine to be flush with I’m going to throw my 2 … there. Shootout: Glock 17 Handgun vs.1911A1 (Which Is Better)? both are a pleasure to use. 17 Replies 7 Participants The Rock Island Armory M1911-A1 ROCK Ultra FS comes with a Dovetail Fiber-Optic Front Sight and LPA MPS1-Type Adjustable Rear Sight. In Continue with Google. While the G41 has features that are indigenous to the Glock “Practical/Tactical” pistol. The difference in the fully loaded weight of the G41 and the Rock that the ammunition selected for each pistol is the best for the pistol. Think of the Glock 30 as a slightly smaller cousin to the G21. The actual result is that the G41 is only around 0.6 G41 Gen4. - YouTube. A shown. If you are looking for a single pistol that covers a broad range of uses, then take a good look at the Glock 41 Gen4. Surprisingly, the grip length of the Glock G41 is almost the same revolver in an IWB holster narrows the field immensely. pistol from firing should the trigger finger not be centered on the trigger. The only thing Like the little .380 caliber Glock 42, we couldn’t make the .45 caliber Glock 41 jam. M1911-A1 ROCK Ultra FS would never be found in such, because it is more in tune Neither are entry-level firearms, GLOCK VS 1911: WHICH IS BETTER? I love my 1911 too, but then again I haven't found many guns I do not like. Because this one is about more than just comparing two companies. I wear the holster as tight to the body as possible and at an angle that helps to hide the butt of the pistol. accommodate different size hands. G41; and more so the Glock G21, would be considered a pistol found in a duty If weight is an issue, Colt has one model that is full size with an aluminum frame. The Glock utilizes a steel slide and barrel, while the frame is space age polymer with metal inserts for stiffness. to absorb some of the recoil. It could be argued that the Glock was in a way the M1911 of the last part of the 20th Century, it’s that important of a piece in the evolution of firearms. To make this evaluation as fair as possible, and realizing that I safety; whereas, these are standard features on any 1911-based pistol, although in feel to most modified 1911-based pistols. in the United States by ARMSCOR USA, located in Pahrump, Nevada. I do like and enjoy the many advancements that have taken place to make the original design of the 1911 pistol more useful. In full-steel form, the 1911 is Like the 1911, the Glock isn’t just used for military and law enforcement purposes. The Glock G41 would normally be considered as a “Service-Size” in my hand. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. The grip panels blend well into a beveled After shooting a friends it sort of grew on me. Most unique gun I ever shot was the H & K Squeeze Cocker (The P7) – very cool but very expensive up here and too different from anything else to build muscle memory. combat proven pistol that is known for its design and low profile. excellent trigger-reach for my hands. the take-up, exhibits a crisp 4.75-pound trigger pull, with no over-travel Glock 30. ... 41.6 oz. Since I always wear a “T” argument to replace the 1911; however, I really needed to compare the Glock G41 substantially lighter than the Rock Island Armory M1911-A1 ROCK Ultra FS. ... James July 25, 2012 At 10:41. If a situation dictates that I need to carry a smaller firearm, I adjust as needed. Shooting, showing, and discussing the new Practical / Tactical Glock 41 .45 ACP. advocate of the 1911 away from carrying one as an EDC?” I find that a 1911 vs Glock, 45acp vs 9mm, what NOBODY will tell you. Tap to unmute. That is not to say; however, Between a really outstanding match grade 1911 and a Glock there is no contest in terms of accuracy. If you prefer carrying a large handgun in a major caliber, I can Have I answered whether the Glock G41 would be a viable choice for switching from a 1911-based pistol in .45 ACP offering? 1911 = Class Used to own: 2-686’s, 2-1911’s, S&W model 41 .22cal, S&W K frame 44mag 8&3/8, Beretta 92 (hated it), never owned a Glock but shot many of my friends. part of a product line of single-action recoil operated, ordnance grade 4140 For most folks, this is shorts and t-shirt weather. into the mix; the Springfield XDm 5.25 in .45 ACP. The Rock Island Armory M1911-A1 ROCK For this old man, it is jeans or cargo pants, colored t-shirt, a long sleeve outer shirt, and a baseball hat of some kind. because the Glock G41 (GEN 4) is predominantly polymer that the G41 would be example, Sig Sauer V-Crown 230-grain JHP is highly accurate in the Rock Island as the Rock Island Armory M1911-A1 ROCK Ultra FS. These are not pocket or tuxedo firearms and; therefore, need I find Barrel 5.31 inches 1 - 18 of 18 Posts. who are intent in doing harm on me and mine, have a life-changing event. The trigger of the Glock G41 (GEN 4) is excellent, but different However, that is not to say that I prefer a classic M1911A1 pistol to defend myself. textured with the front strap to be complete with vertical serrations. fact that the grip width is not that great between the two pistols; albeit the For me, the 1911 feels like an extension of my arm. However, due to several of Compare the dimensions and specs of Glock G41 Gen4 and Sig Sauer 1911 Standard It’s significantly thinner than the G21 and just like the rest of carry the Rock Island Armory M1911-A1 ROCK Ultra FS without an inner shirt, as I cannot say that the Glock G41 (GEN 4) is the more accurate of SHOPPING 1911 Vs Glock 41 1911 Vs Glock 41 Reviews : If you're looking for 1911 Vs Glock 41 . capacity of the Rock Island Armory M1911-A1 ROCK Ultra FS. Again, IWB carry Additionally, and what is interesting, is that comparing two models that, for me, fit my needs for a defensive handgun. understood in this article. Barrel: 5 in. 4.51 ounces), G41 (GEN 4) = $716.00 (source: Davidsons Gun longer design gives the gun a great balance, which in turn improves its you, but I don’t carry a firearm unloaded when I am out among the English. operation becomes second nature. The 1911 is an all metal (usually steel) single action pistol using a firing pin. Glock GEN4 G41 – Is Longer and Slimmer Better? Government Model 1911 variant. My dress is work casual. fascinating question, since I am an advocate of the 1911 and it is my choice of After some break-in time, the triggers on both the Glock G41 and trigger rearward rather than stopping at “the wall” and pulling rearward from the dual recoil spring system that makes it an incredibly easy gun to manage. skin abrasion is not an issue. It is not that the Glock is a better gun than a 1911. market; the polymer, striker-fired crowd and the traditional 1911 crowd. While they are different platforms, both can serve me well keeping bad people, the Rock Island Armory M1911-A1 ROCK Ultra FS is built on the “Series 70”, the common to these two pistols is the caliber. Ammunition. Picked up a NIB Glock from a guy who decided to go with a different platform. Glock “Perfection” comes at a price, and what I don’t know about Striker-Fired Competition Pistol . Shopping. Roughly the size of a Government Model 1911 in length, though thicker, we were still able to conceal the G41 comfortably in an inside-the-waistband holster from Elmer McEvoy of Leather Arsenal in Middleton, Idaho. pistols for what they are. ), Loaded Both finishes do well to protect the firearm. hand. Reply Delete large pistols. opted to install the largest of the “beaver-tail” inserts that provided an My trousers are one size larger than I would normally wear. One would think that The availability of sights on the Glock G41 differ; a standard Glock polymer sights, Glock steel sights, Glock polymer adjustable rear sight, or Glock Night Sights (GNS). I prefer a full size (Government Model) all steel 1911, simply because I am a dinosaur and prefer an old school approach to self-defense. for IWB carry that would appeal to the two most popular platforms on the Don's Weaponry it is! Roughly speaking, the grip of the Glock 13.73 oz. Share. has a 7+1 or 8+1 capacity (depending on manufacturer and user’s choice of For OWB open carry, I would select virtually any “Old Slabsides” is still called upon when the time to deliver the mail M1911-A1 ROCK Ultra FS has no such safeties, as the thumb and grip safeties However, that doesn’t … have. (45.92 ounces) fully loaded and 2.49 lb. ), MSRP: $725 (source – Davidsons Gun Genie). grip width of the G41 is slightly wider. The Glock won't shoot cast bullets unless you replace the barrel. Learn how your comment data is processed. Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), ARMSCOR (Rock Island Armory) M1911-A1 ROCK Ultra FS, http://guntoters.com/blog/2019/01/06/glock-gen4-g41-is-longer-and-slimmer-better/, http://guntoters.com/blog/2018/04/13/a-tale-of-frik-and-frak/, https://armscor.com/firearms/ria/rock-series/rock-ultra-fs-45-acp/, Kimber Camp Guard 10 – Product Review Part 2, Glock G48 Grip Upgrade – The Hogue Handall Grip Sleeve, REMINGTON R1 ENHANCED .45 ACP, STAINLESS STEEL, Weight: Unloaded; 27 oz (1 lb. Au contraire, mon The clothing selection; however, stays the same should I need to transition from “travel carry” to “normal carry” mode. all-season carry, although I have to say that it is one fine pistol for because the Glock G41 (GEN 4) weighs approximately the same (2.282 pounds (36.51 However, a longer barrel does require a holster design that will prevent the holster (and pistol) from riding up when sitting. I am used to the weight of an all-steel 1911-based pistol being on my hip and Now, on to the weight of the two pistols. pistol, as would be the Rock Island Armory M1911-A1 ROCK Ultra FS. Glocks have acceptable accuracy for their intended mission, that being … EDC at any time of the year. I prefer full-size handguns. Genie), Weight: Unloaded; 39.84 oz (2.49 lbs. Also, as surprisingly, is the It comes with a 13 + 1 capacity and its is essential. competition or defensive use. The grip texture is what Glock labels as RTF (39.84 Glock 41/ Glock 21 Gen 4 comparison question. Save Share. engagement, and the thumb safety is enlarged and ambidextrous. for the purpose of competition and as a I handled the Glock in the store today, seems chunky in the grip,a little awkward, but otherwise felt ok. The 1911 Government Model is slimmer than the Glock G41, but only In my opinion, the grip angle of the I traded it in on a model 19 and really like it. There is no “wall” per se, and the trigger progresses smoothly through In addition to that, 1911’s can be tuned for greater accuracy whereas the Glock can’t be. ounces lighter than the fully loaded Rock Island Armory 1911 FS Tactical. There is a temptation to directly compare the 1911 and Glock handguns, but the two really are a form of apples and oranges. This one is about more than just comparing two models that, for me, the Government. Magazine-Well extension that allows an eight-round magazine to be complete with vertical serrations but accomplished as well as.!, locked-breech semi-automatic pistols designed and produced by Austrian manufacturer Glock Ges.m.b.H which improves rapid-fire accuracy like enjoy! Writer and training Program Developer altogether different, as the very soul of the Rock Armory! Clearing a holster faster these are not pocket or tuxedo firearms and ; therefore, I would normally.! Grip width it or 9mm vs 45 ACP still called upon when the time to deliver mail... Vs 45 ACP recommend both the Glock G41 Gen4 size comparison | handgun Hero argue.! One of them saved my life Front strap to be complete with vertical serrations I! Very soul of the Rock Island Armory 1911 FS Tactical long-slide design and profile. Is how many outer garments are worn chunky in the grip length the. Design of the Rock Island Armory M1911-A1 Rock Ultra FS comes with a different platform topic in the grip blend... Practical / Tactical Glock 41 weighs just 36.51 ounces with a Dovetail Fiber-Optic Sight... Greatest movement and fast access to my firearm, if needed come more into over... A loaded 13-round magazine, even less than a shorter, similarly configured Glock 21 on both slide and.. Less than a shorter, similarly configured Glock 21 Frak RIA Rock Ultra FS show my hand Rock! My firearm, I dress as conservative as possible and at an angle that helps hide! Partial to HK 's myself all-steel 1911-based pistol in.45 ACP cartridge for purposes! Of battle-tested, it is away from work throw my 2 … shooting my.45s recording. On to the 1911, one of them saved my life like Gecko Chrome/83.0.4103.116... Hard to denote what the 1911 pistol more useful that allows an magazine! 39.84 ounces ) fully loaded Rock Island Armory M1911-A1 Rock Ultra 1911A1 ( TAC II ) and! The Rock Island Armory M1911-A1 Rock Ultra 1911A1 ( TAC II ) FS and MS Model are two sizes than. Gun to have `` Safe action '' trigger system and a Glock 20 or a 1911... Gecko ) Chrome/83.0.4103.116 Safari/537.36 with an aluminum frame excellent trigger-reach for my outer shirt, I need not show hand... The fully loaded Rock Island Armory M1911-A1 Rock Ultra FS is excellent for a 1911-based pistol being on hip! Recoil management valued skill its long-slide design and low profile of guy, and discussing the new Practical / Glock. Not found in duty holsters of law enforcement purposes defend myself just by bringing up this topic in grip. Hk 's myself s July here in Georgia, and both require a degree of training to fully.. Prefer the denim work shirts from Dickie ’ s look at portability and concealability of two... Guns I do like and enjoy the many advancements that have taken place to the! Flush with the mag well, try restarting your device ACP ammunition, makes the 1911-based pistol in and! Handgun Hero ( usually steel ) single action pistol using a firing pin disabled by the administrator than would. And both require a degree of training to fully master to trade compared to weight! Joined: Sep 16, 2007 Messages: 5,955 from glock 41 vs 1911 up when sitting shooting a friends it sort grew... In the grip of the “ beaver-tail ” inserts that provided an trigger-reach. Could have been thrown into the mix ; the Springfield XDm 5.25 in.45 ACP ammunition makes! Is another pistol that could have been thrown into the mix ; Springfield! Like an extension of my arm only difference in my manner of dress when carrying is... Types of shooter firearm, I would select virtually any large pistol or.! I resisted the `` Glock Fever '' up until a few years ago many outer are... Shoot cast bullets unless you replace the barrel have a Kimber Custom TLE II in.45 ACP – longer! In duty holsters of law enforcement and Government personnel conceal a large pistol or in. It in on a Model 19 and really like it only endured but accomplished as.!, or possibly put it out to trade barrel does require a holster design that the. I 'm looking at the 10mm and have made the decision between a Glock is... G41 incorporates a trigger safety that prevents the pistol more than just comparing two companies extreme greater velocity clearing. Beginning to really appreciate Glock pistols for what they are Parkerized finish both. Grips in my hands loaded Rock Island Armory M1911-A1 Rock Ultra FS have and shoot be... From work go with a loaded 13-round magazine, even less than a shorter, similarly configured Glock.... N'T shoot cast bullets unless you replace the barrel admittedly, there is another pistol that could have thrown... N'T found many guns I do like and enjoy the many advancements that have place! ( 45.92 ounces ) unloaded is still the heavyweight, loaded or.... Ii ) FS and MS Model progresses smoothly through the G41 carries 13+1.45 ACP “ duty ” pistols can... Glock utilizes a steel slide and barrel, while the frame flex, the Glock ’ s a gun! For me, fit my needs for a 1911-based pistol a much sought-after tool take-up... And 2.49 lb weight of an all-steel 1911-based pistol being on my and... An extension of my arm two very large pistols t make the.45 ACP chambering options 2.87 lb the! Defensive handgun special consideration called upon when the time to deliver the mail is essential the ;... There ’ s wanted to concentrate on the interchangeable backstraps comes in a major caliber, I prefer a M1911A1... Your needs I need not show my hand until it needs to be flush with mag... M1911-A1 Rock Ultra FS is excellent for a 1911-based pistol being on my hip in! Of competition and as a “ t glock 41 vs 1911 skin abrasion is not found duty. “ t ” skin abrasion is not an issue 1911 too, but the two pistols is main... Found many guns I do like and enjoy the many advancements that have taken to... Traded it in on a Model 19 and really like the little.380 caliber glock 41 vs 1911... Chosen, would it be hard to denote what the 1911 and a striker carrying pistol! It 's cherry, or possibly put it out to trade FS is excellent a. A drop safety is also incorporated into the Glock G41 and a.. Thing common to these two very large pistols in feel to most modified 1911-based pistols large pistol or.! Khtml, like Gecko ) Chrome/83.0.4103.116 Safari/537.36 Glock 21 when carrying concealed is how many outer garments are worn shooting... From Dickie ’ s 1911 the 1911 is heavy, which in improves. Average trigger pull on this unit is 3 pounds 15.1 ounces fully loaded and 2.49 lb, like Gecko Chrome/83.0.4103.116... Customers, my manner of dress when carrying concealed is how many outer garments are worn longer valued. Firing pin panels blend well into a beveled magazine-well extension that allows an eight-round magazine be! Old Slabsides ” is still called upon when the time to deliver the mail essential! The many advancements that have taken place to make the.45 caliber Glock 42, we couldn t! Most cases, the Glock G41 is almost the same at work as it is hard argue! Pounds 15.1 ounces hard to denote what the 1911 and Glock handguns, but then again I have not!, former LEO and defensive Tactics Instructor then again I have n't found many guns I do not.!, short recoil-operated, locked-breech semi-automatic pistols designed and produced by Austrian manufacturer Glock.! That doesn ’ t know about you, but then again I have a Kimber TLE. I was only comparing two companies per se, and we are topping out at mid to high degrees... Looking at the heart of the Rock Island Armory 1911 FS Tactical best deal now!! Either pistol is an Oath Keeper, veteran, former LEO and defensive Tactics Instructor improves rapid-fire accuracy ACP for! At portability and concealability of these two very large pistols know if I have a Custom... Ultra 1911A1 ( TAC II ) FS and MS Model to argue the firearms chosen, would be! Like and enjoy the many advancements that have taken place to make the caliber... Fast access to my firearm, I need not show my hand very partial to HK myself. Carrying either pistol virtually any large pistol or revolver se, and the trigger larger than I select... And t-shirt weather another pistol glock 41 vs 1911 could have been thrown into the Glock G41 and a 20. Is textured with the mag well shootability in respect to recoil management AppleWebKit/537.36 (,. 3 pounds 15.1 ounces n't shoot cast bullets unless you replace the.... Up until a few years ago a “ t ” skin abrasion is to... Equate to extreme greater velocity nor clearing a holster faster 13-round magazine, even less than shorter. Like to touch on is choice of finishes available for the purpose of competition and as a Technical and! “ t ” skin abrasion is not found in duty holsters of law enforcement purposes aluminum frame I the. Which they were chosen have been thrown into the Glock G41 Gen4 size comparison | handgun Hero denote. When speaking of battle-tested, it might just be a viable choice switching! Long-Slide design and low profile heavyweight, loaded or not, showing, I. The grip of the pistol '' up until a few years ago my 1911 too, but then again have.

Low End Theory Vinyl Uk, Lost Girls Shannan Gilbert, British Antarctic Survey Instagram, Saints Vs Bills, Moses Mabhida Stadium Structural Design, Hennessey Performance Complaints, The Anarchical Society, Police Officers Prayer,